American Idol 2013 – Men and Women “Sudden Death” Round – Week 2 Review
by Jill Mader on March 4, 2013

I’ve lost interest in Idol over the years, and shifting the show to a Wednesday/Thursday schedule (and therefore putting it up against my favorite show, Survivor) really put the nail in the coffin for me – it’s TV for watching while I make dinner or on a Saturday morning now.

So I’ve just watched the two episodes from this week, which were set up the same as last week’s – everyone would perform, and then the judges would choose five to advance. Click through for some thoughts on the performances!



Candice Glover, singing “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman”, made it through. I think that song is a little overdone on Idol, but I liked her controlled performance. She knew when to pull back and when to hit the big notes.

I was disappointed that Jett Hermano didn’t get put through for her slowed-down performance of “Only Girl In The World”, because I thought it was really well done. Better than some performances that did get put through.

Aubrey Cleland, who sang Beyonce’s “Sweet Dreams” also made it through. I like this girl a lot. She chose a difficult song to sing, and I respect that she went for something that didn’t have a lot of big notes but really showed off her range and control. It maybe didn’t stand out as much as it could have, but I think she’s great and could be a frontrunner. (You know, until a flopsy-haired dude in plaid comes and wins the whole thing.)

“Bust Your Windows” is a fun, different song choice, but I wish Breanna Steer had had some more attitude than a scowl. I mean, if you’re not better than the Glee cover version, you maybe should choose another song. Breanna made it through, but I didn’t think she was great.

I’ve been a fan of Janelle Arthur from Hollywood Week, and I thought her cover of “Just a Kiss” was decent. It seemed like nerves got in her way. I’m glad she made it through, but I do worry she might get a little boring.

OK. I know y’all just really want to talk about Zoanette. And I have things to say. I do not like when someone weird is pushed through just for being weird. I like weird, and I don’t like being told that the reason I don’t like something is because I don’t get it. I don’t dislike Zoanettte because she’s kooky, I dislike her because she shouts everything and can’t hit 50% of her notes.



Related Reviews Articles

more articles »

Marvel Comics Weekly Event Review & Spoilers: Death of Wolverine #3 by Charles Soule, Steve McNiven, Jay Leisten & Justin Ponsor With 3 Covers Including Variants!

Blu-ray Review: Gone With the Wind (75th Anniversary Edition)

DVD Review: SpongeBob ScaryPants Collection

DVD Review: Nickelodeon's Let's Learn Patterns and Shapes

Jill Mader

view profile »

Featured Poll

Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.

Recent Comments

Search Pulse




So, with this Simple Jquery Modal Window, it can be in any shapes you want! Simple and Easy to modify : )