Reviewer: “Starman†Matt Morrison
Story Title: Echo: Part 4
Written by: David Mack
Penciled by: David Mack
Inked by: David Mack
Colored by: David Mack
Lettered by: Cory Petit
Editor: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Starman: Hey everyone! Welcome to our review of Daredevil #54. I’m excited to announce that this is the very first review I have ever done with a guest reviewer. And what a guest! We are proud to present everyone’s favorite X-Man… “Logan†aka The Wolverine.
Logan: Make this quick, bub. I gotta go pose for an Iron Man cover in a hour.
Starman: Of course. Now… is Logan okay?
Logan: Suits me.
Starman: Great. I understand you are actually in Daredevil #54?
Logan: Yep. I’m the best at what I do-
Starman: And what is that exactly?
Logan: Cameos.
Starman: Cameos?
Logan: Yep. Hardly a title Marvel published in the last year I haven’t been in.
Starman: Yes. I notice you haven’t been in “Troubleâ€.
Logan: Yeah, well they tried booking me for that, but I’m having creative differences with Mark Millar right now.
Starman: Anything you’d like to talk about?
Logan: (growls slightly)
Starman: So, Logan… what exactly happens in this issue?
Logan: Not much to tell. I stumble across this Native-American woman in the forest. She tries to fight me. We stop. We start talking about vision quests and it ends as I’m getting ready to tell her a story about two dogs fighting.
Starman: A story about two dogs fighting?
Logan: I think there’s an Echo in here.
Starman: And there’s a joke in that line we aren’t going to touch. This story isn’t going to be the joke about the man named “One Man Bucket†is it?
Logan: What joke is that?
Starman: Well, I can’t repeat the whole thing here but it involves Native American twins, the older one being ashamed of his name and the younger one telling a visitor to the tribe “Two Dogs Fighting? No, he’d give ANYTHING to be called Two Dogs Fightingâ€
Logan: Oh. Yeah, that’s a good one.
Starman: Is that the story though?
Logan: No.
Starman: Oh, thank goodness. Getting back to this issue, now the action in the last few arcs has centered on Echo.
Logan: Nice girl. Good fighter. Dunno why she keeps getting called an Elektra rip-off.
Starman: So I expect there’s a lot of good action in this issue since we do have the two of you.
Logan: Oh, there’s some action… but you really can’t see it.
Starman: How do you mean?
Logan: Well, I’m a straight-forward man. Cut right to the point, some might say. But Mack’s artwork… it’s too fancy!
Starman: Well, it does look nice.
Logan: Won’t deny ya that but it’s a little confusing when it comes to the fight scenes. Everything’s all laid out like a board game or a kid’s drawing. Looks cool, but gives me a headache to follow. But the pencil sketches of me are good.
Starman: What do you think about the story? Now, I’m enjoying it quite a bit. I mean, we haven’t seen Echo in the title for a few years and this issue is giving us a chance to adjust her to the many changes in the book since then.
Logan: Yeah. Kingpin got his eyes back and is in jail. Murdock’s identity is kinda out there… but why is this in Daredevil?
Starman: Well, she got her start in Daredevil-
Logan: Has Daredevil been in this story yet? Has Kingpin?
Starman: Uh… yes. For a little bit in the first two parts.
Logan: And what’s happened since then? Last I heard Fisk was in the slammer and Murdock declared himself Kingpin of Hell’s Kitchen.
Starman: Back in #50, yes.
Logan: Well, that’s a damn sight more interesting to me than reading about one of Matty’s ex’s trying to find a new purpose in life now that Hornhead’s got a new squeeze and Kingpin’s already been punished.
Starman: So you didn’t like this issue?
Logan: I like it for what it is. It’s a good story and the girl’s got bite to her, but… I dunno, couldn’t they give her a mini-series of her own? They give me one a month and I could use a break.
Starman: Half and half, huh?
Logan: Yep. Not bad. Not great.
