Mutopia X #3 Review

Reviewer: Andy Campbell

Writer: David Hine
Pencils: Lan Medina
Inks: Alejandro “Boy” Sicat
Colors: Avalon’s Dave Kemp
Letters: Richard Starkings & Comicraft’s Jimmy B
Associate Editor: Nick Lowe
Editor: Sean Ryan
Supervising Editor: Mike Marts
Publisher: Dan Buckley (Marvel)

Just so everyone knows, I’m gonna throw this out there right now: this is the only House of M book I’m reading. I have no interest in the series, and the only reason I’m reading Mutopia X is I like District X so much. That said, I wish there was more to like in this book.

I generally hate “alternate universe” stuff (with a few exceptions, like 1602) because everyone knows that none of the changes will stick. In Mutopia X, aside from certain characters’ lot in life, nothing much has changed: the characters still all behave the same way. Even in this alternate world, Ishmael Ortega cheats on his wife with Lara the Illusionist. That seems like weak writing to me; couldn’t we have come up with something different for the characters to do?

Also, there are a number of plot threads going on at the same time, and yet the book seemed like it was a really quick insubstantial read. With only two more issues to go in this mini-series, I keep waiting for something to actually happen, but it doesn’t seem like anything ever will. If Ortega cheating on his wife again was supposed to be a big event, colour me disappointed.

Nothing against any of the people involved here, as I normally like their work, but if it weren’t for the excellent-as-always art, this book would have scored much lower.

Join our newsletter

never miss the latest news, reviews, live event coverage, audio podcasts, exclusive interviews and commentary for Movies, TV, Music, Sports, Comics, Video Games!