The Dark Knight (2-Disc Special Edition) – DVD Review

There’s always a passing of the guard in nearly every facet of entertainment, some more profound than others. Dwayne Johnson seemingly took the torch of “muscled action hero” from Arnold Schwarzenegger with an oft-forgotten pass by in The Rundown. The Dark Knight featured Heath Ledger taking the torch from Brandon Lee as the “talented young actor who died young right before an iconic role and lives on in t-shirts” part. It just happened that The Dark Knight was the best film of the year and maybe the best of the decade.

“All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.” – Edmund Burke

Christopher Nolan’s take on Batman has been radically different than any of his predecessors by how he looks at the caped crusader. More known for its Rogues Gallery than the man in the black armor, Batman has been a character more about angst than anything else. Nolan has taken this one step further and used Batman as an exploration of the hero; whereas Batman Begins is about the choice of being a hero, The Dark Knight is about the consequences.

Following the dual life of Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale), who spotlights as the protector of Gotham City, The Dark Knight follows him against a new nemesis: the Joker (Heath Ledger). Whereas most criminals want something, the Joker seemingly wants nothing but chaos. Committing robbery and murder without a second thought, the Joker comes to the members of Gotham’s organized crime families as a problem solver. He’ll take care of Batman, but for a price. With new District Attorney Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckhardt) in town to become Gotham’s savior, as well as old friends like police officer Jim Gordon (Gary Oldman), Batman has a brand new nemesis to deal with and an escalation of his war on crime in ways he never could have imagined. Main characters will die, Gotham City will have horrible things happen to it, mortal choices will be made and no one will walk away the same.

Nolan definitely has a character arc in mind when dealing with Batman, as the eventual trilogy is more of a rumination of the nature of the hero than it is a true comic book movie. With gritty, dark tones more in line with a crime film than a comic book film, The Dark Knight takes the best elements of films like HEAT and Bullitt and meshes them around the character of Batman. The Dark Knight, and to a lesser degree Batman Begins, are mainly crime films with superhero grandeur to guide them above the fray. Nolan keeps it grounded, however, by focusing on the character arc he is developing for Batman.

What Nolan seems to be striving for is an extended rumination on the nature of good vs. evil, and why good men fight that good fight no matter what. His point seems to be that part of being the hero is that you can’t go back once the line is crossed; the whole film Bruce Wayne seems to want to let Harvey be the crusader so Batman can disappear and he can have a regular life. But this will never be, as Harvey is destined to become Batman villain Two-Face for starters, as being the hero means committing yourself to an ideal above all else. Bruce Wayne has sacrificed plenty for his hidden life as a crime fighter.

Nolan’s point behind this is that the hero’s work is never done, and that the ability to be the hero is about enduring the negatives. It doesn’t hurt that he has the actor who will go down being the closest associated with his work to help guide him in this existential exploration of heroism. Bale is on top of his game as Wayne for a second straight time, inhabiting the role in a way that no one else has been able to capture. This isn’t a campy superhero that Batman was, nor is it the secondary character in the original series of films; rather, Bruce Wayne/Batman is a conflicted man who tried to adhere to an ideal but finds himself crossing lines and boundaries he thought he never would have to. It’s conflicting and Bale plays it perfectly; we want justice but sometimes the consequences of crossing the line muddle the waters a bit.

For the Joker, the waters aren’t muddled at all. Ledger, in his final completed performance, puts on perhaps his best performance as the incarnation of pure evil. Its fitting that Nolan would expound upon the nature of the hero by bringing in a villain who engenders no sympathy, has no logical reason behind his plans and does things so graphically horrible that there’s no possible way to root for the bad guy. The Joker is in the rare elite of cinematic villains by virtue of Ledger’s performance; when Wayne’s butler Alfred (Michael Caine) speaks of men’s motivations, and how some just want to see the “world burn,” we know exactly why he says the things he does. The Joker isn’t a caricature, like his previous incarnations, and is evil in a way that is frightening to the core. It’s the perfect balance against Batman and Nolan uses the Joker’s low points to balance out Batman’s high points. By the end it’s a matter of attrition between the two; who can outlast and endure.

Evil prevails when good does nothing, Burke thought, and The Dark Knight is a rumination on the nature of the hero from a man who can seemingly do no wrong as a director. The Dark Knight is easily the best film of 2008 so far and it will be hard pressed to find something better as the year goes on. Comic book films have been evolving since the new wave that began earlier this century; The Dark Knight is the genre’s step into adulthood.

Presented in a widescreen format with a Dolby digital format, the film has a very good but not spectacular transfer. On a top notch system it’ll look good but it’s a film that definitely needs the Blu-Ray format to be truly spectacular. As is, it’s just very good.

There isn’t much in terms of special features. The Dark Knight Imax Sequences are the action sequences specifically shot in the Imax format, presented in their full format. It’s interesting to see but not quite spectacular as there’s no commentary or proper placement. Gotham Tonight is a series of character vignettes designed to give some insight into the events that happened before the film. There is a collection of Trailers for the film, as well as two Photo Galleries. A Digital Copy of the film is included as well.

The disc’s main feature if Gotham Uncovered: Creation of a Scene focuses on two things. The Sound of Anarchy focuses on Hans Zimmer’s score, in particular the score that was used for Ledger’s Joker. His goal wasn’t to make a traditional summer blockbuster score, wanting something that would make for an exorbitant amount of tension. Described by Nolan as “razor blades on piano wire,” it’s an interesting piece on that particular aspect of the score. Evolution of the Knight focuses on the Bat Pod and Batman’s new suit of armor. Trying to be able to make the fight scenes more fluid, they worked in the concept of a new suit into a part of the film. They had wanted Bale to be faster and more fluid in the fight scenes, as well as be able to turn his head without having to move his entire body. It’s a 16 minute piece that basically discuses how the character and series had to evolve.

As a DVD set this would be a good start, but unfortunately feels like a quick rush to DVD while a more developed three disc edition is being developed for this spring. The digital copy is a nice touch, but there’s nothing special about the two disc version. If you have a Blu-Ray player, pick up the three disc. If not, pick up the single edition instead of this. The extras aren’t worth it.


Warner Bros. presents The Dark Knight. Directed by Christopher Nolan. Starring Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, Aaron Eckhart, Gary Oldman, Morgan Freeman and Michael Caine. Written by David S. Goyer, Christopher Nolan and Jonathan Nolan. Running time: 152 minutes. Rated PG-13. Released December 9, 2008. Available at

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Join our newsletter

never miss the latest news, reviews, live event coverage, audio podcasts, exclusive interviews and commentary for Movies, TV, Music, Sports, Comics, Video Games!