The Office – Episode 8-7 Review – “Hot or Not?”

Reviews, Top Story

I’ve always been a fan of Pam and Dwight’s weird little friendship, so these past couple episodes of The Office that have highlighted that have really worked for me. In fact, last night’s episode, “Pam’s Replacement”, was probably one of my favorite post-Carell episodes.

Most of the episode centered around Pam feeling that Jim, along with everyone else in the office, was lying to her. Jim wouldn’t admit that the temp she was training to take over for her during maternity leave was attractive, and she was sick of everyone in the office treating her differently and acting as though she looked so sexy nine months pregnant. It was nice to see Pam depicted this way, since I think pregnant ladies on sitcoms so often fall victim to the over-emotional stereotype. Pam is still Pam, and she knows what’s up. And she knew the only person who was still being honest with her was Dwight.

Pam enlisted Dwight to help her prove that Jim thought the new girl, Cathy, is attractive. But somewhere along the way it stopped being a funny joke to play on Jim and started being a little more serious. Pam wondered why Jim had made Cathy laugh so much, and Dwight got way too caught up in proving Jim a liar using a blood pressure test at the local drug store. He thought Jim was lying about everything, but in actuality they discovered that Jim has high blood pressure. It was a surprising way to end the storyline, but it was also one that highlighted just how much Jim and Pam love each other. Pam immediately forgot about Cathy and was just worried about losing Jim.

Meanwhile, when Robert California crashed Andy, Darryl and Kevin’s jam session he completely overtook it by inviting a bunch of other musicians to join in. Darryl ended up on the tambourine, Kevin on the fish (does that instrument have another name?) or poor Andy had to play percussion on his stomach. It was an unexpectedly funny storyline to watch the guys get forced out of their own band while being unable to do anything about it. There wasn’t much to the storyline, but I still found it effective and funny.

Here are some of my favorite quotes and moments from “Pam’s Replacement”:

  • Erin completely screwing up Andy’s plan by telling him his mom is dead in the cold open.
  • Darryl on the phone, telling Andy that it’s a terrible idea.
  • The lunchroom consensus that a pregnant Helen Mirren would be the hottest woman ever.
  • Kelly’s Elin Nordegren reference.
  • “I’m going to write something mean on his wall.” – Kelly, after Facebook stalking the boring-looking dude Jim said he’d set Cathy up with.
  • “No, I’m not going to tell my nine-month-pregnant wife that I find her replacement objectively attractive. I’m also not going to tell my 2-year-old daughter that violent video games are objectively more fun. It’s true, but it doesn’t help anybody.” – Jim
  • Andy: “When you’re in a rock n roll band with somebody, you’re bonded for life.”
    Darryl: “Usually that life is short and tragic.”
  • Andy wrote down lyrics for his scat. Of course.
  • “Jim has no discernible sense of humor, Pam, you should know that.” – Dwight


You can follow Jill at her blog, couchtimewithjill.com, or on Twitter @jillemader Jill has been an avid fan of TV since the age of two, when she was so obsessed with Zoobilee Zoo that her mother lied and told her it had been canceled. Despite that setback, she grew up to be a television aficionado and pop culture addict.