Gaming has come a long way since the 8-bit and 16-bit era, but it seems to have developed into a sector where it feels impossible to win/progress without spending money. The pay-to-win systems have made it so gamers need to spend money to unlock rare cosmetics and powerful weapons. Although many gamers believe that you can still win with skill alone, going up against players who paid for those weapons or cosmetics shows the true power imbalance. No longer are games complete products, but rather part of a live service platform that prompts players to keep spending money to level up.

The iGaming Parallel: How Slots Codified Monetisation
To put this into perspective, it helps to understand how these models function in non-gaming sectors, and a good example of this would be online slots. These follow a variable-ratio reinforcement principle that keeps players spinning or pulling the lever to win a prize. When looking at more popular slots, such as the blood suckers slot demo (as a further example), its high RTP, low volatility, and bonus features are what immediately stand out.
Throw in free spins, and it’s maximum payout is worth 1,014.6x of the player’s initial stake, and you can see why it might be enticing to punters. However, the core issue is that these are gambling-based games, meaning players go into them fully aware they will be spending money. In essence, slot games are there to provide prolonged entertainment for profit, but now it seems this ideal is bleeding over into the gaming sector.
Using Call of Duty: Mobile as an example, purchasing rare mythic skins feels very similar to playing a slots game. An array of cosmetics is laid out in the store alongside the specific skin you might have been eyeing, and you need to spin to obtain it (naturally, each spin costs money). If you are lucky, you might get it on the first try. If not, you keep spending money until you get it. It is now a blueprint found in free-to-play games, where grinding will only get players so far before they need to start spending money.
Engineering the Grind: The Free-to-Play Blueprint
While microtransactions may not be as obvious in some games, it is part of the game’s core functions in titles like Fortnite, Genshin Impact, and CS: GO. This is where the concept of a “Grind Wall” comes into play, with there being an obvious reduction in speed when it comes to player progress when a certain criterion is met.
Usually, when players hit a particular engagement level or specific milestone, there is a difficulty spike, and it becomes impossible to level up further. A consequence of this is that the game’s pacing is now severely impacted, with it no longer taking player enjoyment into account. Instead, it is paced in such a way that an in-game purchase or currency offer looks more appealing. While you can still make some progress, it is at a snail’s pace unless you give in and purchase that Battle Pass or Stamina Refill.
A second consequence is the intentional removal of the core resources needed for player progression, making for a form of artificial scarcity. Suddenly, it is impossible to gain XP or get crucial loot drops, and out of frustration, you purchase them from the game store to avoid your flow being interrupted. Adding this psychological pressure to pay makes a gaming session hard to enjoy, but it forms a large part of how these microtransactions work.
The Corruption of Single-Player Games
While microtransactions are annoying in multiplayer games, it has become more acceptable amongst the gaming community. The real crime, however, is when these pay-to-play models bleed over into single-player games. AAA titles like Mortal Kombat, God of War, and Cyberpunk 2077 are all examples of games you are only expecting to pay for once, and you can enjoy all of their offerings.
However, this is no longer the case with titles such as Baldur’s Gate 3, Red Dead Redemption 2, and even God of War: Ragnarok, where there is an array of in-game purchases. Granted, with some of these, it is not a requirement to purchase in-game items if you want to see progress, but how long until that becomes the case? It seems as if developers deliberately sabotage the core gameplay progression loop to the point where a microtransaction is the only solution.
This is where a third design consequence comes into play: the sense of achievement players get from grinding is stripped away due to this drive for profit. Why would you grind for a rare cosmetic or resource when you can just purchase it from the store? For players who make the effort to grind, it also takes away from their achievements, as it begs the question of why they made the additional effort if other players just bought it.
A good example of this is the current AK-117 Lava Remix mythic in Call of Duty: Mobile. By grinding for it, players can get shards that accumulate until the gun is unlocked, but this method would take them almost a year. In comparison, these shards could just be bought with CP (COD Points), which requires real cash and unlocks it instantly, and it defeats the purpose of grinding.
Loot Boxes and the Devaluation of Art
Of course, only a small percentage of players (usually referred to as “whales”) actually don’t mind spending large sums of money to progress. However, developers seem to cater to this 1% as opposed to the majority of players who would rather grind for their rewards. In turn, this greatly impacts the game’s design, especially when it comes to loot boxes and how Gacha systems are set up. Whales bring in a huge revenue stream, so developers favour them over the common player. This is where art devaluation comes in, as cosmetic designers now need to lower the design quality based on the pricing system.
For free loot box drops, filler content is created where players obtain generic or low-quality cosmetics. As opposed to creating one iconic character or weapon skin players can unlock when they reach a certain level, designers are spending time creating mediocre art. In the cases where there are iconic cosmetics, these are usually locked away in the game store, where players need to pay a huge sum to obtain them. The same can be said when it comes to crates and other rewards you get for levelling up or progressing through the game; it is rare for it to be a sought-after skin or cosmetic.



