| Date | Champion | Defeated | Event | Location |
| 12.15.17 | Dalton Castle | Cody | Final Battle | New York City, NY |
| 06.23.17 | Cody | Christopher Daniels | Best in the World | Lowell, MA |
| 03.10.17 | Christopher Daniels | Adam Cole | 15th Anniversary Show | Las Vegas, NV |
| 01.04.17 | Adam Cole | Kyle O'Reilly | Wrestle Kingdom 11 | Tokyo, Japan |
| 12.02.16 | Kyle O'Reilly | Adam Cole | Final Battle | New York, NY |
| 08.19.16 | Adam Cole | Jay Lethal | Death Before Dishonor XIV | Las Vegas, NV |
| 06.19.15 | Jay Lethal | Jay Briscoe | Best in the World '15 | New York, NY |
| 09.06.14 | Jay Briscoe | Michael Elgin | All-Star Extravaganza VI | Toronto, ONT |
| 06.22.14 | Michael Elgin | Adam Cole | Best in the World 2014 | Nashville, TN |
| 09.20.13 | Adam Cole | Michael Elgin | Death Before Dishonor XI | Philadelphia, PA |
| 07.03.13 | Vacant | - | - | - |
| 04.05.13 | Jay Briscoe | Kevin Steen | Supercard of Honor VII | New York, NY |
| 05.12.12 | Kevin Steen | Davey Richards | Border Wars | Toronto, ONT |
| 06.26.11 | Davye Richards | Eddie Edwards | Best in the World 2011 | New York, NY |
| 03.19.11 | Eddie Edwards | Roderick Strong | Manhattan Mayhem IV | New York, NY |
| 09.11.10 | Roderick Strong | Tyler Black | Glory by Honor IX | New York, NY |
| 02.13.10 | Tyler Black | Austin Aries | 8th Anniversary Show | New York, NY |
| 06.13.09 | Austin Aries | Jerry Lynn and Tyler Black | Manhattan Mayhem III | New York, NY |
| 04.03.09 | Jerry Lynn | Nigel McGuinness | Supercard of Honor IV | Houston, TX |
| 06.30.08 | Jay Lethal | Dalton Castle, Matt Taven, and Cody | Ring of Honor Wrestling | Fairfax, VA |
| 10.06.07 | Nigel McGuinness | Takeshi Morishima | Undeniable | Edison, NJ |
| 02.17.07 | Takeshi Morishima | Homicide | Fifth Year Festival: Philly | Philadelphia, PA |
| 12.23.06 | Homicide | Bryan Danielson | Final Battle 2006 | New York, NY |
| 09.17.05 | Bryan Danielson | James Gibson | Glory by Honor IV | Lake Grove, NY |
| 08.12.05 | James Gibson | CM Punk, Christopher Daniels, and Samoa Joe | Redemption | Dayton, OH |
| 06.18.05 | CM Punk | Austin Aries | Death Before Dishonor III | Morristown, NJ |
| 12.26.04 | Austin Aries | Samoa Joe | Final Battle 2004 | Philadelphia, PA |
| 03.22.03 | Samoa Joe | Xavier | Night of Champions | Philadelphia, PA |
| 09.21.02 | Xavier | Low Ki | Unscripted | Philadelphia, PA |
| 07.27.02 | Low Ki | Christopher Daniels, Spanky, and Doug Williams | Crowning a Champion | Philadelphia, PA |
