| Date | Champion | Defeated | Event | Location |
| 07.11.18 | The Undisputed Era | Moustache Mountain | NXT | Winter Park, FL |
| 06.26.18 | Moustache Mountain | The Undisputed Era | NXT U.K. Championship | London, ENG |
| 12.20.17 | The Undisputed Era | SAnitY | NXT | Winter Park, FL |
| 08.19.17 | SAnitY | The Authors of Pain | NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn III | Brooklyn, NY |
| 01.28.17 | The Authors of Pain | #DIY | NXT TakeOver: San Antonio | San Antonio, TX |
| 11.19.16 | #DIY | The Revival | NXT TakeOver: Toronto | Toronto, ONT |
| 06.08.16 | The Revival | American Alpha | NXT TakeOver: The End | Winter Park, FL |
| 04.01.16 | American Alpha | The Revival | NXT TakeOver: Dallas | Dallas, TX |
| 11.11.15 | The Revival | The Vaudevillains | NXT | Winter Park, FL |
| 08.22.15 | The Vaudevillains | Blake & Murphy | NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn | Brooklyn, NY |
| 01.28.15 | Blake & Murphy | The Lucha Dragons | NXT | Winter Park, FL |
| 09.11.14 | The Lucha Dragons | The Ascension | NXT TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way | Winter Park, FL |
| 10.02.13 | The Ascension | Adrian Neville & Corey Graves | NXT | Winter Park, FL |
| 07.17.13 | Adrian Neville & Corey Graves | The Wyatt Family | NXT | Winter Park, FL |
| 05.08.13 | The Wyatt Family | Adrian Neville & Bo Dallas | NXT | Winter Park, FL |
| 02.13.13 | British Ambition | The Wyatt Family | NXT | Winter Park, FL |
