Stephenie LaGrossa
Survivor Palau, Survivor Guatemala, Survivor Heroes Vs. Villains
Stephenie had a tough time on Palau. Her Ulong tribe is noted as being the worst tribe ever (and they had to have been if they lost more than Pagong). She was dealt a terrible hand and really didn’t have a shot. But she more than made up for that when she was given another chance on Guatemala. While I didn’t like the fact that Stephenie and Bobby Jon were brought back immediately after they had already played, if we leave this fact aside, it was clear that Stephenie was there to play. She cut players mercilessly and while Danni ended up with the win, I still maintain that it should have been Stephenie.